NCAA DIVISION III ALL-AMERICANS
| 2007 |
| Emily Lesher, jr. (200 backstroke) |
| Emily Lesher, jr. (200 IM) |
| *Emily Lesher, jr. (400 IM) |
| 2006 |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, sr. (100 butterfly) |
| Emily Lesher, so. (200 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, so. (400 IM) |
| 2005 |
| Emily Lesher, fr. (400 IM) |
| 2003 |
| Cheryl Roubian, sr. (100 backstroke) |
| 2002 |
| Cheryl Roubian, jr. (100 backstroke) |
| Cheryl Roubian, jr. (200 backstroke) |
| 2001 |
| Cheryl Roubian, so. (100 backstroke) |
| Cheryl Roubian, so. (200 backstroke) |
| 1994 |
| Kim Schneider, sr. (50 freestyle) |
| Kim Schneider, sr. (100 freestyle) |
| *Kim Schneider, sr. (100 butterfly) |
| 1993 |
| Kim Schneider, jr. (50 freestyle) |
| Kim Schneider, jr. (100 freestyle) |
| Kim Schneider, jr. (100 butterfly) |
| 1985 |
| *Kama Grattet, sr. (1-meter diving) |
| Kama Grattet, sr. (3-meter diving) |
| 1984 |
| *Kama Grattet, jr. (1-meter diving) |
| *Kama Grattet, jr. (3-meter diving) |
NAIA ALLMERICANS
| 1983 |
| Kama Grattet, so. (1-meter diving) |
| Kama Grattet, so. (3-meter diving) |
| Donna Johnson, so. (200 backstroke) |
| Donna Johnson, so. (200 IM) |
| Donna Johnson, so. (400 IM) |
AIAW ALL-AMERICANS
| 1982 |
| Kama Grattet, fr. (3-meter diving) |
EMPIRE 8 ALL-STARS
| 2007 |
| Emily Lesher, so. (Swimmer of the Year) |
| Martie Staser (Coach of the Year) |
| Morgan Flanagan, jr. (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Kate Kukan, jr. second team (100 breaststroke) |
| Kate Kukan, jr. second team (200 breaststroke) |
| Emily Lesher, jr. first team (200 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, jr. first team (400 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, jr. first team (200 backstroke) |
| Lauren McKinney, fr. first team (200 butterfly) |
| 200 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Lauren McKinney, Meghan Okoniewski), second team |
| 400 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Lauren McKinney, Meghan Okoniewski), second team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Lauren McKinney, Kaitlin Shearman, Amy Mehltretter, Emily Lesher), first team |
| 2006 |
| Emily Lesher, so. (Swimmer of the Year) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, sr. first team (100 butterfly) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, sr. first team (200 butterfly) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, sr. second team (100 breaststroke) |
| Kate Kukan, so. second team (200 breaststroke) |
| Emily Lesher, so. first team (200 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, so. first team (400 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, so. first team (200 backstroke) |
| Amy Mehltretter, jr. second team (200 freestyle) |
| Amy Mehltretter, jr. second team (500 freestyle) |
| Amy Mehltretter, jr. first team (1,650 freestyle) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Meghan Okoniewski, Jen Dahm, Brittany Beane, Amy Mehltretter), second team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Meghan Okoniewski, Amy Mehltretter, Aubrey Kirchoff, Emily Lesher), second team |
| 200 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Aubrey Kirchoff, Meghan Okoniewski), second team |
| 400 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Aubrey Kirchoff, Meghan Okoniewski), first team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Aubrey Kirchoff, Meghan Okoniewski, Amy Mehltretter, Emily Lesher), second team |
| 2005 |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, jr. (Swimmer of the Year) |
| Emily Lesher, fr. (Rookie of the Year) |
| Martie Staser (Coach of the Year) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, jr. first team (100 butterfly) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, jr. first team (100 breaststroke) |
| Aubrey Kirchoff, jr. first team (200 breaststroke) |
| Kate Kukan, fr. second team (200 breaststroke) |
| Emily Lesher, fr. first team (200 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, fr. first team (400 IM) |
| Emily Lesher, fr. first team (200 backstroke) |
| Amy Mehltretter, so. first team (200 freestyle) |
| Amy Mehltretter, so. first team (500 freestyle) |
| Amy Mehltretter, so. first team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Meghan Okoniewski, fr. first team (50 freestyle) |
| 400 freestyle relay (Meghan Okoniewski, Amy Mehltretter, Aubrey Kirchoff, Emily Lesher), first team |
| 200 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Aubrey Kirchoff, Elizabeth Walsh), first team |
| 400 medley relay (Emily Lesher, Kate Kukan, Aubrey Kirchoff, Meghan Okoniewski), first team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Aubrey Kirchoff, Meghan Okoniewski, Amy Mehltretter, Emily Lesher), first team |
| 2003 |
| Kristie Kern, sr. first team (1-meter diving) |
| Kristie Kern, sr. second team (3-meter diving) |
| Cheryl Roubian, sr. second team (100 backstroke) |
| Cheryl Roubian, sr. second team (200 backstroke) |
| 2002 |
| Lisa Elsemore, sr. (Swimmer of the Year) |
| Lisa Elsemore, sr. first team (400 IM) |
| Lisa Elsemore, sr. first team (200 breaststroke) |
| Kristie Kern, jr. first team (1-meter diving) |
| Kristie Kern, jr. second team (3-meter diving) |
| Cheryl Roubian, jr. first team (100 backstroke) |
| Cheryl Roubian, jr. second team (200 backstroke) |